STR Fees Increase as More Convert to Long Term Rentals
Charles Phanumphai • January 13, 2025
Why More Cities in Grand County Are Adding STR Pressure—And Why Homeowners Are Shifting to Long-Term Rentals
In recent years, cities and towns across Grand County, Colorado, have increased pressure and costs on short-term rental (STR) homeowners and operators. This trend reflects a broader effort to manage the impact of STRs on communities while addressing housing affordability issues. One recent example is the Grand Lake Board of Trustees’ decision to raise fees and deposits for various licenses, including nightly rental licenses, starting in 2025.
Fee Increases in Grand Lake
The new fee structure for nightly rental licenses in Grand Lake represents a significant cost hike for STR operators. While the one-time application fee remains unchanged at $165, the annual license fees have increased considerably. Here’s a breakdown of the updated fees based on occupancy levels:
1-3 Occupancy: $700 per license
4-6 Occupancy: $900 per license
7-10 Occupancy: $1,100 per license (a 22% increase from $900 in 2024)
11+ Occupancy: $2,000 per license (a newly added tier)
These fees must be paid annually to renew a nightly rental license and maintain compliance with local regulations. According to Grand Lake Treasurer Heike Fawkes, revenue from these fees funds the town’s general operations, attainable housing initiatives, program advertising, code enforcement, and other administrative costs. In 2024, the town collected approximately $84,000 from nightly rental licenses, and that figure is expected to rise in 2025 due to the fee increases.
Why Are Fees Increasing?
Under municipal codes, towns like Grand Lake have the authority to update fees to offset the direct and indirect costs of administering STR programs and mitigating their impacts on the community. These impacts include:
Strain on Housing Availability: STRs often reduce the availability of long-term rentals, contributing to a housing shortage for residents.
Community Concerns: Increased tourist activity can lead to noise complaints, parking issues, and other disruptions.
Administrative Costs: Running STR licensing programs requires funding for advertising, enforcement, and compliance monitoring.
The Shift Toward Long-Term Rentals
As STR costs rise, many homeowners who are barely covering their expenses are reevaluating their options. Here’s why more homeowners are making the shift to longer-term or seasonal rentals:
Rising Costs and Complexity: Higher fees, stricter regulations, and increased administrative burdens make STRs less financially appealing.
Stable Income: Long-term rentals provide a consistent income stream without the seasonal fluctuations of STRs.
Reduced Oversight: Managing a long-term rental typically requires less oversight and fewer resources compared to the constant turnover and upkeep of STRs.
Community Impact: Some homeowners are motivated to contribute to local housing solutions, offering their properties to residents rather than tourists.
Many of these homeowners are turning to Snow Capped Properties to manage their long-term rentals. As one of the largest—if not the largest—long-term rental companies in the Winter Park to Grand Lake area, Snow Capped Properties manages over 75 properties and is continuing to grow. Their expertise and local presence make them a go-to partner for property owners navigating the transition to long-term rentals.
Conclusion
For STR homeowners in Grand County, the financial and operational challenges of maintaining a nightly rental license are growing. As cities like Grand Lake continue to implement fee increases and other regulatory measures, many property owners are finding that transitioning to long-term rentals offers a more sustainable and community-focused alternative.
Whether driven by economic necessity or a desire to address housing needs, this shift highlights a critical moment for Grand County’s rental market. Homeowners navigating these changes should carefully evaluate their options to ensure their properties remain both profitable and aligned with community priorities.
🏔️ Fresh Ideas, New Opportunities, and a Clear Path Forward in Grand County!
🏔️ Do you own an investment property in Grand County?
Today’s closing was a great reminder that the answer sometimes goes well beyond the transaction itself
Grand County's real estate market has shifted, and we're seeing an interesting parallel between homeowners trying to sell and those reconsidering short-term rentals.
The Right Partner Makes All The Difference
Another Happy Homeowner
What the New Federal Housing Bill Could Mean for Homeowners
All Under One Roof
Winter Park's aerial transit system is moving through a serious planning process, and if you're renting, buying, or owning property here, it's worth understanding where things stand. Locals have heard this before. The town's own website calls this vision three decades in the making, and most of us have watched it surface and disappear more than once. What's different now is the structure: a rezoned base area, a $2 billion master plan, Alterra on record financing the gondola, and for the first time, specific design concepts in front of Town Council.
Not Ready to Sell? Renting Could Be the Perfect Next Step.